Dark River! or Long Shadows...

[Falcon]

Yay, I started a topic! My favorite book was Dark River, so far. Maybe even Long Shadows. I didn't read Sunrise yet . . . I like Dark River mainly because it focuses a lot on my favorite character, JAYPAW! Woo, go Jaypaw! It was mysterious and really kept your attention for the most part. I'd give it 9 out of 10 stars (just because I wish it was longer! ) or I suppose, if it was out of 5, I'd give it the full 5. Yes. In Long Shadows Sol just made me angry, but it was really attention grabbing. Some parts I couldn't put the book down . . . What are your opinions on these books??

[Whitefur]

Hmm....Sunrise was pretty good. It was harder to guess the plot then in the other books and was a little more mysterious.
I'd have to say that Long Shadows was my favorite because of the epic three-chapter battle! THREE CHAPTERS!
It was great. All the Clans fighting on ThunderClan territory!

Dark River was to.... well, it was slow. I started reading it again but I couldn't do it!

[Whitfur]

Sorry! I said Long Shadows was my favorite book with the epic battle!
I meant Eclipse!
Eclipse has the epic battle and stuff!

[Iceflower]

idk, it's hard to choose

[Sponsored content]